Moralize.us alpha 
Is it right or wrong for you to push a fat man off a bridge in front of a speeding train to stop it from killing five people?
wrong the fat man isn't involved in the situation, and doesn't deserve to have his life taken away from him.
right More people live, he's fat anyway
right more people are saved
right Ok, now this in the scenario you popped from out of nowhere and said "I'm a time traveller, right, five people, Michael Moore, sure thing", and I would give it a go. Otherwise I'd wait for McGuyver to execute the plan.
wrong uncertanty of sucess, (reword the question)
right exception: chris farley
wrong it's man slaughter
wrong not even a fat guy has enough mass to stop a train killing five people.
wrong no man is fat enough to stop a train
wrong I'm not comfortable deciding someone's fate
right One less fatty.
right there are too many fat people anyway
right you're saving more people than killing.
wrong either way you look bad. Just hope the fat man jumps himself!
wrong a fat bloke won't save five people from a train, you just end up with 6 dead, one of which I murdered
right 1 < 5
right the man IS Michael Moore
right 1 < 5. Although I can't say I see how it would stop the train from killing five people. :P
right How fat is this fucker? If he can stop a speedy train 'm pretty sure I'd have an hard time pushing him over a bridge.
right it's pretty clever to use the mass of a fat guy to stop a train.
wrong then I would decide about the fat man life
right he's fat.
right yes cause your saving more people by sacrificing the fat guy
wrong even if he was the fattest man on Earth, he wouldn't stop a speeding train
wrong Although one is greater then five, how can you be so sure pushing the fat man will stop it from killing five, even if you can see into the future it is the fat mans decision to use his life to save five, not yours.
wrong all lives are not valued equally; I lack the information needed to make a valuation; if he knows his life to be worth less than the five then he can jump himself
wrong the fat man is Michael Moore.
right it's funny when fat ppl die
right he's fat
right fat people are too heavy to fly to Heaven.
wrong the needs of the many DO NOT outweigh the needs of the few. If it was Michael Moore I would be ok with it though.
55% 45%
Please join and share whether or not this is right for you. (email not required)