About | Join | Sign-in

Moralize.us alpha

Is it right or wrong for you to obey the commandments if it means harming another?

obey the law ?

flip a switch that will cause an out of control train to change tracks and kill one person if it means saving five people ?

 

wrong I don't really even need to explain my answer here. Right?

right I live for myself, not for another

right if you choose to follow a morale code and think it is right to stick with it - stick with it

right That is a vague and open-ended question. Which one, how? The idea behind doing right is that it stands against safety and comfort, but you would need a lot more specifics. (You guys do realize "don't murder" and "don't steal" are in there too, right?)

wrong no commandements should be more important than other people

wrong dont be animal, think!

wrong obedience to any set of laws does not excuse anybody from morality

wrong Of course it's wrong

wrong you should always avoid harming another human beign

wrong It's wrong to obey rules that have no logic whatsoever. Commandments are just stupid laws for stupid people.

wrong FUCK YOUR GOD. People come first.

wrong While I can't necessarily forsee this situation, one person has absolutely no right to negatively impact the life of another person intentionally. There is no excuse!

wrong I will not listen to a command that is against my moral fibre.

wrong harming others for the sake of obeying arbitrary rules is wrong.

wrong a simply reading the ten commandments reaveal that a fair amount of um' are batshit crazy.

wrong Harming another person is not justified by an arbitrary rule.

wrong other peoples life can be more important that commandments

wrong The point of the commandments is to provent harm to a person

wrong I do not believe the commandments come from god.

wrong I know as an individual which actions are best for me in any given situation

 

15% 85%

 

Please join and share whether or not this is right for you. (email not required)